Posted: Mon Jun 04, 2007 7:40 pm
cutlass wrote:Ughhh, bloody hell.
Look: just take your brown crayon and color them and be done with it.
No really, do you have less fun gaming because of this?
'less fun' no, because stereotypes and racial bias is so ubiquitous in science fiction of all types that it's kind of the 'background'. However, it would make things more fun if science fiction would detatch itself from the biases that hinder it. Most sci-fi is perused by undersexed white guys, so most of it shows how that demographic sees the world... unfortunately.
It just goes to how things are portrayed, which is an interesting thing to think about. Right now, I think that the CS is portrayed like the USA, mixed racially, but the further up the command chain you go, the whiter and maler it gets. It just is something I point out since it's so ubiquitous in science fiction. White guys in charge, if there are non-whites, they're always subordinate (A black guy will often get to be a second in command, but he's never going to the #1 guy), and almost no women, except for the inexplicably gorgeous warrior woman who's been a fighting for decades and yet magically is not only unscarred, but only looks in her mid 20's.
From Azure Bonds to Red Sonja to the CS's own blonde bombshell, there comes a point where the authors are putting in stereotypes rather than characters, and that does weaken things. Admittedly, Kashbrook is a step foreward in that she doesn't have a fully environmental MDC bikini that she wears into battle... but come on. Joseph Prosek's lived a life of pampered lunxury, so if he looks like a pretty boy, it's understandible. But Kashbrook is supposed to be an omnicompetant and battle-hardened woman of almost 50 years of age!
And I do think it would make the CS stronger villains if it was otherwise. If, say, half the generals were women. Or if The Proseks were mulatto. Same genocidal politics, same humano-centrist focus. You know, show a Humanity which really has seemed to overcome barriers of gender and race.... it just sold its soul in order to do it. It's also a place where the "American Facist State" has never gone. American Nazis have been done in science fiction for years, as have science fiction Nazis. However, gender neutral race balanced Nazis.... not something you see, but something that the CS has the opportunity to be.
This is America. In America, genocidal facism is something that every young boy and girl should be able to aspire to, regardless of race, creed, or color!