drewkitty ~..~ wrote:I presented my evidence to the minimum limitations on how quickly anyone can get new tattoos. (See the quote from the Atlantis book.)
No, you presented a quote from a logically and structurally vague paragraph which can be interpreted any number of ways....which forces us all to look elsewhere for evidence no matter which side of the 'argument' we're on.
Any extra tattoos would come under the heading "GM discresion"and "Game Play", so would not fall under any 'book rule'.
And yet, repeatedly in the history of the Books, when there are conditions whereby exceptional service can be rewarded by extra [fill-in-the-blanks], the Authors have not hesitated to say so.
But in the case of Magic Tattoos, they never, ever say in any book that Loyal Minions can get awarded extra....and they never instruct the GMs to award extra tattoos between levels to good players, either.
When we can't get a definitive, set-in-stone statement from the authors, we are forced to go on circumstantial evidence; and in this case, the fact that "Extra Tattoos for Exemplary Service" are NEVER mentioned in any book, where 'extra rewards for good playing' bonuses are replete throughout the books, is a strong circumstantial argument in favor of T-men being 'locked out' of any more than 1-2 Tattoos per level of experience, maximum.
And, the only thing I would be conflicting with you is when you use the word 'Only' when you say something like 'they only get new tattoos at their level ups.' in reference to the tattooed men classes.
While yes, that is when they Normally get new tattoos. That is not the Only time they Can get new tattoos.
I say "only" because the only circumstantial evidence that we have, lends itself to that argument.
We have a rather badly-worded paragraph, and so we must find other sources of information; in this case, just sticking by the paragraph alone isn't enough. Again, if you can find some info to the opposite, the answer will change. But right now, I would say, the available evidence seems to go against you.
:wink: Of course they are going to write the classes so to give GM's ammunition to Limit Munchkins from turning their chars into powerhouses.
Typically, NPCs are writen up as powerhouse examples of their respective RCCs/OCCs.
However, NONE of the NPC T-Men (and by the way, this includes Slither, the Maxi-Man from Rifts Dimension Book Three: Phase World Sourcebook, who I just remembered), in ANY book, break the formula.
If I could find you so much as a single NPC whose Tattoo numbers and character level didn't follow the formula, then I would gladly tell you the opposite; I'm not interested in an Internet Win.
Not even C.J. Carella's known NPC T-Men, who are almost invariably at or near the maximums for those OCC/RCCs like virtually any NPC he ever created, breaks the formula.
So let's do a recap of what we know so far:
- No mention of either loyal or outstanding NPCs being given extra tattoos between levels by grateful Masters in any book.
- No out-of-game mention or direction for GMs to give their own players extra Tattoos between levels.
- A series of NPC Tattooed Men of various types, in Books written by authors as diverse as C.J. Carella (Pantheons of the Megaverse and Rifts: Mercenaries), Mark Sumimoto (Rifts: Splynn Dimensional Market), Carl Gleba (Rifts Dimension Book Six: The Three Galaxies), Tood Yoho (Rifts: Adventures in Dinosaur Swamp), and of course Kevin Siembieda himself (Rifts: Atlantis, Rifts: Africa and Rifts: England), none of whose NPCs have tattoos in sufficient numbers to break the formula.
- The fact that the Authors of the Books typically try to balance out a given OCC beforehand, combined with the fact that IF Tattooed Men could just wait around and scoop up Tats every six months without any other limitations, gathering MDC and PPE in the process, the resulting imbalance of that character compared to other, 'similar' OCCs (is the T-Man a Man At Arms OCC, or a Magic one?) would be something the authors would almost certainly have foreseen and avoided.
- The fact that even those Chiang-Ku who are Tattoo Masters, and who can make new Tattoos at any time they wished, also don't break the formula.
- The fact that, in Rifts: England, Chiang-Ku themselves, the undisputed masters of Tattoo Magic and its very creators/originators, are explicitly limited to an even greater degree than humans are (see page 49 of the same book, re: the Chiang-Ku R.C.C.) -which circumstantially and logically leads one to conclude that if even the powerful Chiang-Ku is explicitly limited, then humans can expect to see some limitations in the realm of New Tattoo Acquisition as well.
As I said earlier, I'm not looking for an Internet Win or anything, and I await someone who can come forth with an example of an NPC whose total number of Tattoos for their character level doesn't follow the whole 1-2 Tattoos, or some other information to the contrary.
EDIT: While scrubbing the
Rifts: England Book one more time, I also happened upon Sir Prrcyval and Sir Galahad, the former a Chiang-Ku Tattoo Master in disguise, and the latter an Atlantean Undead Slayer.
Neither one of those NPCs broke the formula, either.
And when you have EVERY T-Man in EVERY book follow the same apparent formula, what other objective conclusion can be drawn for what the Authors apparently intended this OCC to do?