Point Blank Called Shots...

You are on your own. The Army is MIA and our government is gone! There are no communications of any kind. Cities and towns have gone dark, and zombies fill the streets. The dead have risen and it would seem to be the end of the world. Help me, Mommy!

Moderators: Immortals, Supreme Beings, Old Ones

User avatar
GreenGhost
Adventurer
Posts: 720
Joined: Fri Aug 11, 2006 12:38 pm
Location: Colorado
Contact:

Point Blank Called Shots...

Unread post by GreenGhost »

I came across a situation last night while GMing for Dead Reign. The players were making Called Shots throughout the game, which was fine. Later they got to where they were engaging Zombies at point blank range and still making Called Shots. I know how Called Shots work in normal situations, but what would the Target/Strike Roll be for making a Called Shot at Point Blank Range? I would think the roll should be lower than normal, but what should it be? Is there a rule on this in any book or is it House Ruled?

Thanks in advanced. :-)
Semper Fi
OOH-RAH!
0331/0321
User avatar
krispy
Hero
Posts: 910
Joined: Fri Sep 28, 2007 11:12 pm
Comment: Luck favors the prepared
Location: Down Under

Re: Point Blank Called Shots...

Unread post by krispy »

thats an interesting point....hmmm

we all know an Aimed & Called shot takes 3 attacks & a standard Called Shot takes 2 attacks (& only for single shots not bursts)

there are also penalties on a Called Shot when going for a bull's-eye or small target with a penalty of -3 or -4 (sometimes more) to strike

i would also factor in weapon type (guns arent my forte, so i can be corrected) and the grappling Zeds. what i mean by this is i assume it might be easier to aim a hand gun at the head of a Zed up close while its wrestling with your arms or trying to choke you rather than a pump action shot gun or hunting rifle.

so i would implement some level of penalty for a Called Shot when up close & personal with the Zeds
connecting the dots
User avatar
GreenGhost
Adventurer
Posts: 720
Joined: Fri Aug 11, 2006 12:38 pm
Location: Colorado
Contact:

Re: Point Blank Called Shots...

Unread post by GreenGhost »

krispy wrote:thats an interesting point....hmmm

we all know an Aimed & Called shot takes 3 attacks & a standard Called Shot takes 2 attacks (& only for single shots not bursts)

there are also penalties on a Called Shot when going for a bull's-eye or small target with a penalty of -3 or -4 (sometimes more) to strike

i would also factor in weapon type (guns arent my forte, so i can be corrected) and the grappling Zeds. what i mean by this is i assume it might be easier to aim a hand gun at the head of a Zed up close while its wrestling with your arms or trying to choke you rather than a pump action shot gun or hunting rifle.

so i would implement some level of penalty for a Called Shot when up close & personal with the Zeds


That makes sense in grappling situations, but since point blank is within 10 feet, what about point blank that isn't quite in a grappling position?
Semper Fi
OOH-RAH!
0331/0321
User avatar
krispy
Hero
Posts: 910
Joined: Fri Sep 28, 2007 11:12 pm
Comment: Luck favors the prepared
Location: Down Under

Re: Point Blank Called Shots...

Unread post by krispy »

GreenGhost wrote:
krispy wrote:thats an interesting point....hmmm

we all know an Aimed & Called shot takes 3 attacks & a standard Called Shot takes 2 attacks (& only for single shots not bursts)

there are also penalties on a Called Shot when going for a bull's-eye or small target with a penalty of -3 or -4 (sometimes more) to strike

i would also factor in weapon type (guns arent my forte, so i can be corrected) and the grappling Zeds. what i mean by this is i assume it might be easier to aim a hand gun at the head of a Zed up close while its wrestling with your arms or trying to choke you rather than a pump action shot gun or hunting rifle.

so i would implement some level of penalty for a Called Shot when up close & personal with the Zeds


That makes sense in grappling situations, but since point blank is within 10 feet, what about point blank that isn't quite in a grappling position?


i forgot to ad that in. i dont see much difficulty in hitting a zed in the head point blank (within 10ft and not being grappled) due to their slow movement so i understand what Josh Hilden said

but for Fast Attack - man i played Red Dead Redemption Undead Nightmare edition and their fast attacks they were near impossibly to shoot in the head real time & sometimes difficult in bullet time cos they would tuck their heads under etc

so for Fast Attacks i would implement the penalties when attempting to hit a fast, agile moving target
connecting the dots
User avatar
Mercdog
Hero
Posts: 810
Joined: Mon Apr 13, 2009 1:49 am
Location: Montana, USA

Re: Point Blank Called Shots...

Unread post by Mercdog »

Page 182 of DR has close combat firearm rules. Take 'em or leave 'em as is your want.
Blade with whom I have lived.
Blade with whom I now die.
Serve right and justice one last time.
Seek one last heart of evil.
Still one last life of pain.
Cut well old friend...
and then farewell.
-Sir Orin Neville Smyth, Flight of Dragons
User avatar
azazel1024
Champion
Posts: 2550
Joined: Thu Jul 23, 2009 9:43 am
Comment: So an ogre, an orc and a gnome walk in to a bar...
Location: Columbia, MD

Re: Point Blank Called Shots...

Unread post by azazel1024 »

I am with Rhomphaia, though with a two handed melee weapon I'd say point blank range is within 5ft. I would have any ranged weapon do an additional die of damage at point blank range as well.

I hate to say it, but I come back to d6 rules being a bit more realistic when it comes to ranged combat. Both increasing difficulty at longer ranges to hit (short, medium, long and extreme ranges for most d6 systems), as well as reducing damage. So a weapon might have a range of 10/50/100/200m for ranges (and associated standard difficult targets to roll to strike at those ranges) and a damage of 4d/3d/2d/1d for damage. Though that is a bit extreme drop off in damage, but in a d20 setting, maybe 2d6+1/3d4/2d6/2d4 might be more appropriate. Its more dynamic to worry about in combat, but it provides a hair more realism.
User avatar
The Galactus Kid
Palladium Books® Freelance Writer
Posts: 8800
Joined: Tue Jul 20, 2004 4:45 pm
Comment: THE SPLICE MUST FLOW!!!
Location: Working on getting Splicers more support!!!
Contact:

Re: Point Blank Called Shots...

Unread post by The Galactus Kid »

I always play that an aimed shot takes 2 actions and give you the aiming bonus.

Called shots need a 12 or better with modifiers to hit.

Aimed called shots still only take two actions, but need a 12 or better to hit with modifiers.
Image
Ziggurat the Eternal wrote:I'm not sure if its possible, but if it isn't, then possible will just have to get over it.

Ninjabunny wrote:You are playing to have fun and be a part of a story,no one is aiming to "beat" the GM, nor should any GM be looking to beat his players.

Marrowlight wrote: The Shameless Plug would be a good new account name for you. 8-)

ALAshbaugh wrote:Because DINOSAURS.
User avatar
Rockwolf66
Hero
Posts: 1058
Joined: Wed May 17, 2006 12:50 am
Location: GPass area oregon

Re: Point Blank Called Shots...

Unread post by Rockwolf66 »

Well personally I use the firearms rules from the Compendium of Contemporary weapons. With one major modification aimed and called shots do not cost more than one attack. the reason being is that if you are proficient with the weapon you are aiming the weapon. As far as the called shot goes I have friends who do Submachinegun matches once a month and other firearms competitions on their other weekends. Some of the people who are once a month competitors can hit head sized targets at a dead run. Point blank just means that you hit faster while retreating to make room to shoot.

With melee weapons I can tell you from personal experiance that you do end up targeting limbs with disabling cuts before you go for the kill. With Zombies and melee someone would find themselves parrying or cutting off the arms followed by an attack to the neck. Maybe with a Zweihander you would get someone cutting zombies in two but that still doesn't kill the zombie.
"Having met a few brits over here i wonder about them. The Military ones I met through my dad as a kid seem to be the most ruthless men on the planet..." -Steve Hobbs
User avatar
krate
Explorer
Posts: 148
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2008 11:37 pm

Re: Point Blank Called Shots...

Unread post by krate »

You are not alone. That rule does seem odd to me as well.
Please visit my DeviantArt page http://krateworx.deviantart.com/
User avatar
Oberoth
Dungeon Crawler
Posts: 343
Joined: Tue Jan 27, 2009 7:55 am
Location: Wisdom

Re: Point Blank Called Shots...

Unread post by Oberoth »

Yes. IMO this is a BS rule. Really, what makes the head (And neck) any more or less difficult to hit than say an arm, wrist or knee cap?
Image
User avatar
Rockwolf66
Hero
Posts: 1058
Joined: Wed May 17, 2006 12:50 am
Location: GPass area oregon

Re: Point Blank Called Shots...

Unread post by Rockwolf66 »

RGG wrote:I'm sure this was play tested...17... mind you most of the time your running or shooting or attacking from behind a barrier so that may be the reason for the 17 no bonus roll. We decided to go with using a bonus if your are in the open or on a roof top shooting down at the zombies. That seems like the best way to handle that rule. In hand to hand combat we also allowed the bonus... What have hand to hand training if you do not get to use it?????

So long as there is room to move and fight, no barriers are in the way we allowed the bonus. other wise 17 was always needed in our game. You may want to adapt the same gaming rule.


Yeah...Uh...Right.

From what i can tell it's an arbitrary rule that was tossed in without playtesting nore common sense applied. Basically it's the rule of "A 10 year vetran of the SAS Counterrevolutionary warfare group who is trained to hit a man in the head at 15 yards. Now has the same chances as a little girl fireing her brother's .177 airrifle for the very first time ever. It just does not work when common sense is aplied. From the rumors i have heard it was put in to make the game more suspenceful. It doesn't make the game more suspencefull it makes the game less playable and enjoyable.

There is a reason I use the rules found in the Compendium of Contemporary weapons...they both work in game and are fairly realistic down to the shock and bleeding out.
"Having met a few brits over here i wonder about them. The Military ones I met through my dad as a kid seem to be the most ruthless men on the planet..." -Steve Hobbs
User avatar
Oberoth
Dungeon Crawler
Posts: 343
Joined: Tue Jan 27, 2009 7:55 am
Location: Wisdom

Re: Point Blank Called Shots...

Unread post by Oberoth »

Rockwolf66 wrote:"Yeah...Uh...Right.

From what i can tell it's an arbitrary rule that was tossed in without playtesting nore common sense applied. It doesn't make the game more suspencefull it makes the game less playable and enjoyable.


I agree. The thing is that Kev and crew have always stated that the player characters are not merely just average people. Even the Ordinary Person OCC is an above average "Super hero". I want my character to be able to do THIS in a pinch. :D
Image
User avatar
dargo83
Dungeon Crawler
Posts: 265
Joined: Fri Jan 09, 2009 6:52 am

Re: Point Blank Called Shots...

Unread post by dargo83 »

most of my players are like that all the time one of them is from the air force then went into the FBI part of the fugitive task force and the other is trained by myself (former MP) is my girlfriend.
Post Reply

Return to “Dead Reign™”