Nether wrote:Pepsi Jedi wrote:Nether wrote:Pepsi Jedi wrote:Yeah they have wings, but they also have huge jet engines providing thrust. With out those jet engines pushing the plane forward and thus air around the wings, they don't glide very far, if at all. yes there are glide ratios for those big planes but they're NOT what you might think they are. As for the spinning, that's easily explained as when the electricity started to go out, the computers went a bit haywire and extended or retracted flaps or something then they locked like that. Not quite as plausible as the plane just going dark and then starting to pitch forward and 'glide' straight into the ground. But possible. The one that landed close by could have been in the midst of a turn when the power went out and it spiraled due to that. Later in the episode we saw some planes had come in to land intact. (( The almost rape scene when they went in the plane)). The thing is, we don't yet know why the power went out like it did. It wasn't a normal act of physics. Even batteries stopped working. It's not like the juice just stopped flowing. A fundamental law of physics was altered/changed. So there's no way to possibly anticipate how planes and other things might be effected by such a change. (( Again I point out this .... was very very much inspired by the SM Sterling series, where the exact same thing happened and one of hte protagonists was actually IN a small plane when it happened and had to try and land with no power.))
Definately not true.
All modern commercial jets like boeing and airbus are also gliders in a sense. Even without fuel or power the pilot can still "glide" the plane in and i believe an airbus 380 (one of the bigger planes) had this exact issue. The thing glided for a very long time considering to a military base on a small island.
So if this happened, planes wouldnt just be falling out of the sky, they are still relatively safe until the landing, which might cause problems. Even helicopters are 'fairly' safe if they only lose power/fuel as the propellers will spin reverse as it falls, allowing for enough cushion on crash dropping that the passengers should be alive, and usually ok.
"You belive" "they 'can'" "A very long time"
Can you give something real and concrete to this? Other than "No I don't think you're right" and vagueness? And Autorotation is not what any chopper pilot is going to call 'fairly safe'. it's a very dangerous very bad day.
Yes, with out thrust or lift, planes fall out of the sky, big commercial airliners are not gliders. They're barely flying rocks. lol.
NO, it's not! I already gave you the basic info that you could have easily googled to confirm what i said was true. This isnt a rpg book where the only way to look up info is to flip thru the book for citation, and we aren't lawyers defending 'only' one side of the arguement.
Your comment shows your knowledge in this area is devoid, which is fine but your statements are blatantly wrong.
Also i was not claiming all planes, primarily modern commercial jets which are not front heavy prop jobs.
So here ya go, I even took like 30 sec to find this for ya.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_Transat_Flight_236
On the otherhand, what you are saying is YOUR Opinion which I'm not sure what you based that on, but regardless it's wrong.
9 Minutes man. And they had power from emergency means. With out those the plane wouldn't have staid up that long. The emergency ram air turbine was deployed, " to provide essential power for critical sensors and instruments to fly the aircraft." 33,000 feet down is 3,666 feet down per minute. And with out the sensors and instruments... sploosh.
Not to mention they had an hour of prep time from the first indication of problem till they lost the last engine. The planes in the show lost ---- all power---- instantly, at night, with out warning.